German Shepherd Protection Dog - ChrischaYou’ve pulled up a breeder’s webpage. Everything on the website looks right. The dogs are titled both in working and in show venues. The dogs have health certificates, and may even have been breed surveyed in Germany. The full registered names are listed, and pedigrees are either posted or are linked to an online database where prospective buyers can search them. The information on this breeder’s dogs is visible, posted, and verifiable. The breeder sounds like they have a lot of experience in the breed. They definitely are not a backyard breeder, but something seems off, and you can’t quite put your finger on it.

Perhaps you clicked on the “Upcoming Litters” page, and saw many different litters all due in the same three-month window. Or perhaps you saw that one stud was being used for six of the breeder’s females, all bred around the same time. Or perhaps you are reading through their puppy information, and are seeing prices in excess of $2500 for an 8-week-old puppy, with the price rising ever higher depending on the “level” of puppy you want: “first choice”, “premium”, “ultra-premium”, etc. There is even a convenient “Pay Now!” PayPal button, where you can put a down payment on a puppy, sight unseen. These signs indicate that you may have stumbled upon the website for a large-scale or  commercial breeder.

Commercial and Large-Scale Dog Breeders

What defines a commercial breeder? This definition varies by state, with some states saying as little as three breeding females makes one a commercial breeder, with other states saying 30 or more breeding dogs makes one a commercial breeder. In the vernacular, the term “commercial breeder” is used to designate a breeder who houses large numbers of dogs (often in USDA-approved kennels, keeping them compliant with animal welfare laws), breeding litter upon litter of puppies to sell across the U.S. These are the puppy mills that typically supply pet stores with purebred papered puppies, but they also sell their puppies to buyers through the Internet. The conditions in which these dogs are bred and raised are deplorable, and little concern is given to the breeding dogs themselves, nor to the puppies. Indeed, the issue of purchasing a pet store puppy has been covered in detail from multiple reputable sources, as well as by the standard animal “rights” groups. Commercial breeding operations should be avoided if you want a healthy, carefully bred, properly socialized German Shepherd puppy! Similarly, purchasing a puppy from a pet store should never be an option, as no reputable breeder sells their dogs to a pet store!

Then there are the large-scale dog breeders. These breeders do not supply puppies to pet stores, but still use puppy-producing as their sole income. They often have huge kennel facilities to warehouse all their dogs, but some only keep a small number of kennels and dogs on their property, and farm out their females to their “associates”. They stick to one specific breed, rather than multiple breeds like many commercial breeders. While the definition of large scale breeders is somewhat nebulous, a large-scale breeder is generally characterized by the following:

  • A large number of active dog breeding females (usually 10 or more).

Many of these females have been ‘farmed out’ to other people (friends, family, associates, other breeders), who then whelp the litter for the breeder. Having such a large number of breeding females allows this breeder to produce puppies year round, thus ensuring a very steady and lucrative flow of income. If you pull up the “Females” page of the website and see a dozen active breeding females, then you are most likely looking at the website of a large-scale breeder.

  • A large number of puppies produced every year.

This begs the question of “what is a large number of puppies?” Many states mention “in excess of 30 dogs produced annually” in their definition of commercial breeder. But for prolific GSD females, this could be three litters of 10 puppies (from three different females), which is an acceptable number of litters and puppies for a breeder. But if the breeder has, say, six litters over a three-month period, this could produce in excess of 50 puppies in that short period, which can translate to over 200 puppies in a year! This is excessive.

Many large-scale breeders now only list their litters by a seasonal period, to make it look like they have a smaller number of litters per year. But if the website lists multiple litters of puppies all due within the few months, then the breeder may be a large-scale breeder (unless these are the ONLY litters they are producing at all this year; some breeders do “group” their litters, but still only produce a few litters per year.).

  • Main income and livelihood is provided by dog breeding and selling puppies.

Good breeders generally do not use their breeding program as a money-maker. The true cost of breeding, whelping, and raising a litter is astronomical when done correctly. The only way for a breeder to actively make money off of their breeding program is to turn it into a full-time breeding operation that produces puppies year round. And this is exactly what large-scale breeders have done in order to turn a profit and make a living from their dogs.

  • Lack of involvement in a legitimate training club.

Good breeders are actively involved in their local Schutzhund club. Very few large-scale breeders are involved in a local Schutzhund club, nor any other kind of working dog club. Their goal is simply to breed dogs and produce puppies for sale, not to actually be involved in the training, titling, and working of the dogs. They pay other people to do this for them, so that they can then breed the finished product.

One of the benefits of titling a dog is getting to know and understand who this dog really is and what he brings to the table genetically in terms of temperament, working ability, and drives; this is then used to make informed breeding decisions. By not being involved with their own dogs, large-scale breeders bypass this entirely, and are producing puppies by relying solely on their observations of physical appearance and  on others’ second-hand observations of their dogs.

These are the breeders described in the opening paragraphs. The websites look fantastic. The dogs are titled, and typically are imported from Europe. Most tend to be black-and-red German show lines, produced by the large kennels in Germany that breed prolifically in their aims to produce, use, and sell top VA-rated dogs (although large-scale working line breeders do exist). The large-scale breeder’s website may triumphantly proclaim the various accomplishments of the parents, and it often does sound quite impressive to see all those titles and breed surveys and show ratings on their breeding animals. The puppies are numerous, and you can almost order one to your specifications given the sheer number of litters they have available over the year. There often is very little wait, and very little screening, because this type of breeder needs to move puppies, and move them fast!

While this type of breeder does use titled, tested dogs, there are still some serious pitfalls that come with supporting a breeder whose entire livelihood centers around making and selling puppies, especially since good large-scale breeders are few and far between.  We will look at these pitfalls if purchasing a puppy from most large-scale breeders in our next blog, while also addressing the characteristics that those few good large-scale breeders have in common. In the meantime–Buyer Beware!



Red Flags: Backyard Breeders

by Carissa on March 27, 2014

Kuehn-picRegionalsWith an increasing number of breeders turning to the Internet to create more of a presence for themselves and their dogs, it is important for potential puppy buyers to know how to sift through their websites to determine a good breeder from a mediocre breeder. This blog looks specifically at red flags that indicate a poor quality “backyard breeder”. A “backyard breeder” generally is anyone who breeds their purebred dog without any regard for health, temperament, genetic screening, or proof that the dog is actually breedworthy. If you are looking for a healthy German Shepherd puppy with a stable temperament and good genetics, then you want to stay away from these types of breeders!

Red Flags that Indicate “Backyard Breeder”

1. “Shepherd” is misspelled.

Every good breeder knows how to spell the name of their beloved breed. If the website says “Sheppard”, “Shepard”, “Shephard” or any other various misspelling of “German Shepherd”, move on.

2. Dogs are listed only by call name, with no links to pedigrees or full registered names.

Full registered names are searchable, and can be used to verify health, titles, and pedigrees. Coincidentally, full registered names are rarely listed on the websites of backyard breeders, leaving the potential buyer unable to research the breeder’s breeding dogs to verify the pedigrees and health information.

Good breeders are proud of their dogs, and will always list or provide the full registered names. They have nothing to hide, and want potential puppy buyers to know what other dogs, accomplishments, and bloodlines are behind their dogs. If all you see are call names no matter where you go on the site, move on, especially if they are not linked to the dog’s full pedigree that contains their registered name.

3. No pedigrees are available anywhere on the site, and cannot be found in any online database.

BrunoPedPedigrees are so much more than “papers”. A pedigree is a valuable tool for helping evaluate and trace specific bloodlines, traits, temperament, and working ability through generations. Good breeders know how to read and use a pedigree, and know the genetic strengths and weaknesses of their dogs and of the dogs behind them in the pedigree. They typically post the pedigrees online using one of the several online databases for German Shepherds such as Pedigree DatabaseWorking Dog.EU, or WinSis-CAT online (please note: anyone can edit Pedigree Database and, so always double-check the information!), or will provide a copy upon request. This pedigree on the left is of the sire of John’s dog Bruno vom Midlicher Land IPO3, and is from WinSis-CAT online, which uses trial results to verify pedigree information. Breed surveys, titles, hip and elbow ratings, and more are also recorded on the pedigree.

Backyard breeders, on the other hand, usually just view pedigrees as proof that the dog is purebred. They do not know how to evaluate the strength or quality of the pedigree, nor how to use it to trace the genetics behind their dogs. They typically know little about the genetic history behind their dogs, other than that all the parents and grandparents were “AKC-registered” or “papered”. They will not be able to explain the genetic strengths, weaknesses, temperament, and potential health issues behind their dogs, because they do not know this information. If they provide the pedigree upon request, it typically is full of several generations of untitled, untested dogs. 

If this is the case, then move on and look for a more knowledgeable breeder who truly understands the genetic history of their particular dogs, and who uses dogs of better quality in their breeding program.

4. The breeder’s main claims are that the dogs are AKC-registered, or that their dogs come from “Champion Bloodlines”.


We have discussed this myth of AKC registration being an indication of quality in a previous blog. But another commonly tossed around phrase is that of “champion bloodlines”. You may hear explanations like: ”Well, she comes from champion bloodlines from Germany”, or “There’s lots of Schutzhund titles behind him, and his great-grandfather competed in the WUSV”. But then an analysis of the pedigree reveals several recent generations of untitled, untested, backyard bred dogs before you eventually find good dogs who had been proven before breeding. Thus, their “champion bloodlines” and Schutzhund-titled dogs may be four, five, or even six generations back in the pedigree, where they now exert little influence on the current generation of dogs.

Because all dogs in Germany must have a breed survey, show rating, and at least a SchH1 title before being bred, any dog that has ancestors from Germany will therefore have titles somewhere in the pedigree. Since the GSD breed arrived here in America after World War I, with increases in imported dogs seen again after World War II, all GSDs here in America will eventually have titled dogs from Germany generations back in their pedigrees. However, this does not mean that this current dog in the breeder’s backyard is therefore of breeding quality!

More important than what distant ancestors have accomplished is what the dogs most recent in the pedigree have accomplished. Have THEY proven themselves breedworthy, and if so, how? Have they actually DONE something besides sit in the backyard and make puppies? Were they titled, and the parents titled? Or is it just several generations of untitled backyard-bred dogs, who eventually have titled European dogs several generations back? If this is the case, move on. Look for a breeder who has proven their dogs to be breedworthy BEFORE they were bred, and who does not just rely on the accomplishments of distant ancestors to “sell” their puppies.

5. No health certifications are listed, and cannot be proven by the breeder.

Hip xrays: OFA GoodHip and elbow certifications should be listed at a minimum, and many breeders are choosing to test for DM (Degenerative Myelopathy) as well. If done through the Orthopedic Foundation For Animals (OFA), the record of the hip, elbow, and DM ratings may also be found in the online database at Some breeders send their hip and elbow x-rays into Germany to be certified through the SV. Either way, proof of valid hip and elbow certifications should be provided.

These basic health tests for the GSD breed ensure that the breeding dogs are free from potentially painful and crippling genetic disease, and therefore have a much lower risk of passing this on to puppies. Hip and elbow dysplasia can only be diagnosed conclusively through radiographs (x-rays). Excuses like “my vet said they looked great”, “the dog comes from a long line of good hips”, “they’ve never shown any signs of hip problems” do not cut it! The physical symptoms of these diseases are vague, chronic, and often mimic other conditions. Thus, x-rays must be taken, and must be read by expert radiologists to truly show what is happening in the hip and elbow joints.

Never take a breeder’s word for it; ask for proof, and if it is not provided, move on. Find a better breeder who truly cares about the health of the dogs they use, and of the puppies they produce.

6. No working titles of any kind are listedor there are invented titles after the dog’s name.

Good breeders train and work their dogs in a meaningful venue besides basic obedience. Backyard breeders typically just breed their dogs and do little else with them besides having them produce puppies and live in their house as a pet (or live in the backyard). However, the German Shepherd Dog is a working dog first and foremost, not just a “pet dog”!  Work and temperament have been linked from the very beginning of the breed; each one needs the other in order to maintain the German Shepherd breed.

Invented titles include “titles” like “Personal Protection Level 1”, “Executive Protection Dog Level 2”. These are not actual certifications or titles that are awarded by any legitimate organization. Personal protection is something the dog does; it is not something the dog earns based on a performance against a standardized set of rules in front of an objective judge, who is continually evaluating the genetic temperament and working ability of the dog. The breeder of the dog pays to have personal protection training put on their dogs, and then declares it as a “title” without ever having the dog evaluated by an objective outside party. Thus, personal protection “titles” do not sufficiently test the temperament of the dog, and are not evidence of breedworthiness!

Certificates like Canine Good Citizen (CGC), Temperament Tested (TT), Herding Instinct Certified (HIC) are not working titles. These are basic certifications that do little to test the actual genetic working temperament and abilities of the dog. Look for IPO titles, advanced obedience titles, advanced agility titles, advanced herding titles, legitimate Search and Rescue, Explosives Detection, or Patrol Dog certifications. These titles should be verified as well; many results are searchable, and the dog’s name should show up in trial results. Titles in protection sports like IPO are especially important for working breeds like the GSD.

We have written about the importance of working titles on dogs in the past. While titles are not “everything” (as many are fond of pointing out), legitimate titles show that the dogs are capable of being trained and worked, have had their temperament tested in a venue outside of their own backyard, and show that the breeder does more with their dogs than just breed. If the dogs are being bred without having their temperament and working ability proven, move on and find a better breeder.

7. There are no photos or video of the dog working or performing any meaningful activity.

BrunoGood breeders post working photos and videos of their dogs. They are proud of the accomplishments of their dogs, of their working ability and character and temperament. Mediocre or backyard breeders have nothing to brag about, because they do very little with their dogs except breed them; they simply avoid or hide this issue altogether by posting only a few glamour shots of their dogs: head shots, the dog standing in a stack, or of the dog laying down in the backyard or playing ball.

If there is no proof of the dog being anything other than a pet or lawn ornament, move on! Keep an eye out for pictures stolen from other  breeder websites, as well.

8. Dogs are purposely bred out of standard.

This includes the breeder whose dogs are advertised as being “huge”, “oversize”, “Old World”, or a “rare color” like white, liver, and blue. The breeder should KNOW what the GSD is, and the GSD is none of the above! This “breeder” shows that they do not know nor care to adhere to the standard that makes the GSD what it is. Why, then, are they breeding and selling “German Shepherd puppies” if they show a complete disregard for what the breed is supposed to be?

While there are plenty of puppy buyers out there who think it is “cool” to own a ‘rare shepherd’, they really are buying backyard-bred dogs of inferior quality that have been bred for only one aspect: appearance. Health and temperament are rarely PROVEN before breeding, and  both health and temperament problems abound in these “special” GSDs. The pedigrees typically contain generation after generation of untitled, untested dogs that were bred simply because they exist as intact animals.

The breed standard exists for a reason, to ensure that the German Shepherd Dog remains a German Shepherd Dog. German Schutzhund Judge Dietmar Schellenberg poignantly sums up the situation:

“To meet an ever-growing demand, some breeders betray the characteristic temperament traits of working dogs…many of today’s behavior problems are the direct result of this irresponsible breed manipulation.” (Top Working Dogs)

9. Dogs are bred before two years of age.

Backyard breeders often have little knowledge of canine reproduction and of the proper breeding recommendations for the breed. For German Shepherd Dogs, the minimum breeding age is two years old. This was instituted for several reasons:

    • To allow the dog to fully mature both physically and mentally
    • To reduce the risk of breeding complications, and of pregnancy and whelping complications
    • To allow time for the dog to be appropriately trained, titled, and proven before breeding
    • To allow time for genetic screenings like hip and elbow x-rays to take place. OFA certification, for example, requires that the dog be a minimum of two years of age.
    • To allow time for the breeder to uncover the genetic strengths and weaknesses of their dogs, so as to make informed breeding decisions

If the “breeder” is breeding females before they are two years old, or has stud dogs who are only one year old, run the other way! This breeder shows a complete disregard for the health and well-being of their breeding dogs, not to mention a complete lack of knowledge of canine reproduction. Why support a “breeder” who knows so little about breeding, and who apparently cannot be trusted with properly caring for their breeding dogs (let alone puppies)?

These are just a few of the most obvious and glaring red flags that indicate a mediocre or backyard breeder. If you choose to buy a puppy from a breeder like this, you do so at great risk and often at great long-term cost, once health and temperament issues surface in the dog. You might get lucky and get a great dog that is healthy and happy, or you might be one of the thousands of owners posting on the various German Shepherd message boards and online forums, asking for help with all the health and temperament problems of their backyard-bred German Shepherd puppy they got “for a great price”.

 Next blog we will discuss the red flags on breeder websites that indicate a large-scale “commercial” breeder who breeds to make money off producing lots of puppies, instead of breeding for good German Shepherd Dogs.


Breeder Websites: Buyer Beware!

March 14, 2014

When beginning the search for a new German Shepherd puppy, most people turn to one of the most readily available tools around: the Internet. But the Internet can be a double-sided coin. On one side, anyone can post whatever they want, without being held accountable for the truthfulness of the content. This certainly carries a […]

Read the full article →

How Life Will Change With a German Shepherd

February 26, 2014

Adding a German Shepherd dog to your household is a life-changing endeavor. This is not a decision to be taken lightly, because life will forever be different with a German Shepherd puppy running around, requiring puppy proofing of the home, restriction and boundaries for the first year or more, active training and involvement from the […]

Read the full article →

Understanding the German Shepherd

February 14, 2014

The German Shepherd Dog is one of the most popular dog breeds in the U.S., remaining a top choice not only for police and military work but also for companionship. Sadly, this same popularity has given rise to a large number of so-called “breeders” (backyard breeders, puppy mills, commercial breeders) who regularly release a glut […]

Read the full article →

Show Titles: Just for Pretty Dogs?

February 9, 2014

Breeding for the “Show Ring” Breeding for the conformation ring, or “show ring”, has been blamed by many people for ruining a range of once-workable breeds, from Golden Retrievers and Labs to Dobermans and German Shepherds. When it comes to selecting a German Shepherd, this belief has led many pet owners to avoid those “slope-backed” […]

Read the full article →

Power of Protection

January 27, 2014

No phase of Schutzhund has received more criticism and been steeped in more controversy than the protection phase. Ever since Schutzhund’s introduction here in the U.S. in the mid-1950s, the bitework portion of the sport has continued to raise eyebrows and draw harsh criticism from “animal rights” advocates and even some breeders. Even the AKC bowed […]

Read the full article →

Do Titles Really Matter?

January 17, 2014

When it comes to serious competitors in the sport of Schutzhund/IPO, titles on the puppy’s parents matter, because these show that their future puppy is receiving its raw genetic material from parents that were successful in the sport. But for someone looking for just a pet German Shepherd puppy, does it matter whether a breeder […]

Read the full article →

Honoring Officer Kevin Tonn

January 14, 2014

On January 15, 2013, the world lost a great man in the line of duty. In the year that has followed this tragic event, the legacy of Kevin Tonn — his character, devotion, passion, sacrifice, friendship, and service — has become widespread throughout the Central Valley and across the nation. We would like to take this time […]

Read the full article →

New Year’s Resolutions

January 8, 2014

It is one week into the new year, and many of us have formed New Year’s Resolutions. Whether your resolution is to eat healthier, get more exercise, or spend more time with family, we encourage you to think of your dog, too, when making new resolutions! Want to get more exercise, or get more fit […]

Read the full article →